|
|
||||||||
1 Canadian Cooperative Wildlife Health Centre, Department of Veterinary Pathology, Western College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada S7N 5B4
2 Department of Veterinary Biomedical Sciences, Western College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada S7N 5B4
3 National Wildlife Research Centre, Canadian Wildlife Service, Carleton University Campus, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada K1A 0H3
4 Corresponding author (email: gary.wobeser{at}usask.ca)
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Key words: Aquila chrysaetus, Canis latrans, carbofuran, Haliaeetus leucocephalus, pesticide poisoning, Vulpes vulpes.
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| MATERIALS AND METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Most suspected poisoning incidents occurred in late autumn, winter, or early spring, so many specimens were or had been frozen prior to submission. The interval between death and collection of animals was unknown in most cases. Animals were thawed at room temperature prior to necropsy. Because examinations were done over an extended period by 11 pathologists, methods varied somewhat; however, multiple tissues were collected and processed for routine bacteriology and histopathology from all eagles, except for those with advanced autolysis, and from most wild carnivores. Brain tissue removed from animals was frozen at 20 C prior to AChE analysis. A modification (Blakley and Yole, 2002) of the Ellman procedure (Ellman et al., 1961) was used to measure brain AChE activity. Results were expressed in micromoles of acetylthiocholine iodide hydrolyzed per minute per gram of tissue (wet weight [µmol·min1·g1 of tissue]) at 25 C. Activity was compared with normal animals of the same species previously examined in the laboratory (Table 1
). Esophageal or stomach contents from eagles involved in six incidents in 1994 and 1995, and from a coyote involved in an incident in 1995 in which no eagles were detected, were examined by Zenon Corporation, Burnaby, British Columbia, Canada, under contract to the Canadian Wildlife Service using multi-residue pesticide analysis that examined for the potential presence of 124 organic compounds (pesticides and metabolites). The laboratory was accredited by the Canadian Association of Environmental Analytical Laboratories and used standard methodologies (Greenberg et al., 1992; US Environmental Protection Agency, 1992).
|
In selected instances, AChE activity was measured after chemical reactivation using pyridine-2-aldoxime methochloride (2-PAM) and reactivation after gel filtration and dilution (Westlake et al., 1981). Stomach contents of a few birds were examined for the presence of strychnine following extraction with chloroform and dilute sulfuric acid using ultraviolet spectrophotometric techniques (Blakley, 1984). Lead content of the liver of several birds was determined by atomic absorption flame spectrophotometry at 219 nm following dry ashing of the tissue (Kim et al., 1990).
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
|
Poisoning of eagles by insecticides was confirmed by chemical analysis in eight incidents (Table 3
). Carbofuran was identified in each case. The metabolite 3-hy-droxycarbofuran was detected together with carbofuran in four incidents. The organothiophosphorus insecticide terbufos (S-tert-butylthiomethyl 0,0-diethyl phosphorodithioate) was found in addition to carbofuran in one incident. No other pesticide was detected. In three other confirmed poisonings, a person admitted to authorities that carbofuran was placed in bait at the site. In four of seven events in which only carbofuran was identified, brain AChE activity in the eagle(s) examined was not reduced from normal, although coyotes from three of these sites had >50% reduction in brain AChE.
|
In six of 13 incidents considered suspicious for anticholinesterase poisoning, based on finding dead eagles together with other dead wild animals, brain AChE of eagles or coyotes was depressed by >2 SD but <50% of the reference mean.
In addition to the 54 incidents in which eagles were found dead, there were eight incidents in which coyotes were found dead with no mention of eagles in the record. Brain AChE activity in coyotes in these incidents ranged from 0.53 to 0.97 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue (approximately 6080% reduction from normal; Table 1
). Carbofuran (24 ppm) and 3-hydroxycar-bofuran (0.07 ppm) were detected in the stomach content of a coyote found dead in 1995; brain AChE activity in this animal was 0.92 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue. A magpie found with a coyote at one site had brain AChE activity of 1.6 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue (about 8% of normal), and two ravens found with a coyote at another site had brain AChE activity of 1.78 and 1.74 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue, respectively. We have no reference value for ravens, but the activity in these birds was much less than reference values for other corvids (magpie [19.5 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue; Blakley and Yole, 2002]; American crow [Corvus brachyrhynchos, 20±3.4 µmol·min1·g1; Hill, 1988]).
The following examples illustrate two situations in which poisoning was recognized. Between 24 and 27 November 1997, 12 dead coyotes and one dead and one live bald eagle were found within 600 m of a cow carcass at Braddock Reservoir, Saskatchewan (50°05'N, 107°22'W). The live eagles wings and tail were spread, there was froth and meat in its beak, and its talons were clenched; it died shortly after discovery. The dead eagle was 25 m from a scavenged coyote. The eagles and 11 coyotes were examined. The eagles were adults (male, female) in excellent body condition, with large amounts of flesh and intestines in their esophagus. Brain AChE activity of the dead eagle was 4.32 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue. After 2-PAM and gel filtration reactivation, brain AChE activity was 8.3 and 11.0 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue, respectively. Substantial reactivation following gel filtration alone was suggestive for carbamate involvement. Brain AChE activity in the eagle found alive was 4.85 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue. Six coyotes had been consumed partially by scavengers, and five had identifiable stomach content (hide, rumen, omasum) compatible with having fed on the cow carcass. Brain AChE activity in the two coyotes tested was 1.19 and 0.94 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue, respectively. There was no appreciable reactivation after treatment of the first of these brains with 2-PAM, but the AChE activity was 8.92 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue after gel filtration. The results were interpreted as presumptive of poisoning with a carbamate pesticide (Westlake et al., 1981; Smith et al., 1995). The following spring, two bald eagles and a coyote were found on the melting ice of the reservoir. The eagles were adult females in good body condition with crops filled with decomposed mammalian viscera. Their brain AChE activity was 10.1 and 13.3 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue. The coyote found was in good condition and had brain AChE activity of 1.58 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue. A presumptive diagnosis of carbamate poisoning was made.
On 1 December 1999, an adult male bald eagle was found 3 m from a scavenged fox carcass near Fairy Glen, Saskatchewan (53°03'N, 104°33'W). The eagle was hunched over with fluid from its beak and fox fur clenched in its talons. It was in moderate body condition, with intestines, flesh, and fox fur in its esophagus. The fox was in moderate body condition; the abdominal and thoracic viscera were missing. Brain AChE activity of the eagle and fox were 3.33 and 0.89 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue, respectively. This was classed as a presumptive diagnosis of anticholinesterase poisoning.
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Based on the common association between poisoned eagles and coyotes, we believe that most eagle deaths were secondary to intentional illegal poisoning of coyotes, as described by Allen et al. (1996), although eagles may have fed directly on poisoned baits in some situations. In two incidents associated with beehives, the target may have been black bears (Ursus americanus) or skunks, rather than coyotes. Secondary poisoning of raptors usually results from ingestion of unassimilated pesticides in the alimentary tract of the primary victim (Hill, 1995; Mineau et al., 1999). In many incidents, abdominal viscera were missing from coyote and fox carcasses from which relatively little muscle had been removed by scavengers. Both carbofuran and terbufos are readily available insecticides in western Canada. Carbofuran, the most commonly identified compound, is very poisonous for mammals and has one of the highest recorded toxicities to birds of any pesticide registered in Canada (Mineau, 1993, p.1). Birds and mammals usually die within a few minutes of exposure or recover quickly with little evidence of toxicity (Hill, 1995). Secondary poisoning of raptors has been documented where carbofuran was used on crops (Mineau, 1993; Elliot et al., 1996), and the compound has been used for deliberate poisoning of raptors (Mineau, 1993; Mineau et al., 1999).
Brain AChE activity is used commonly to identify anticholinesterase poisoning, but interpretation is difficult for specimens collected in the field because chemicals have a variable effect on AChE, and the level of exposure, time period, and conditions between death and specimen analysis are highly variable. The interval and conditions between death and submission were unknown for most animals in this review; however, most specimens were collected during cool to cold weather, and many were frozen when they reached the laboratory. It is unlikely that brain AChE activity would have decreased as a result of decomposition in these animals, because brain AChE is very stable for up to 12 days of postmortem decomposition at temperatures up to 25 C (Burn and Leighton, 1996), but spontaneous reactivation may have occurred. Interpretation of brain AChE activity is particularly problematic when carbamates are involved because birds may die from high levels of exposure resulting in rapid death from neuromuscular blockage, which may prevent significant penetration of the central nervous system (Westlake et al., 1981), and because binding of carbamates to AChE can reverse spontaneously (Martin et al., 1981; Hill, 1989). Spontaneous reactivation of brain AChE postmortem has been documented in the laboratory (Hill, 1989) and in poisoning cases involving carbamates (Mineau and Tucker, 2002a,b). Birds poisoned by carbamates may have little or no reduction in brain AChE. American wigeon (Anas americana) collected promptly after death from a field sprayed with carbofuran had significantly lower brain AChE activity than wigeon found dead a day later, and only one of six wigeon examined had brain AChE activity reduced by >50% (Hill and Fleming, 1982). Only three of six red-winged blackbirds (Agelaius phoenecius) that died after exposure to carbofuran had any reduction in brain AChE; the maximum depression was 48% of normal, and the bird with the highest concentration of carbofuran in gut content had no AChE depression (Augsberger et al., 1996). This pattern was evident in eagles known to have ingested carbofuran (Table 3
). Based on the 15 incidents in which both eagles and canids were examined from a site, brain AChE activity in coyotes and foxes appears to be a more reliable indicator of poisoning than AChE activity in secondary avian victims.
Under ideal conditions, normal animals of the same species and age that have been exposed to the same conditions between death and analysis should be used as controls for diagnostic cases; however, this was not possible. Reference values used were generated in the same laboratory using the methodology used for the diagnostic cases. The AChE activity in the reference eagles was similar to that reported by other laboratories using modifications of the same basic technique (Table 4
). Since publication of the values by Blakley and Yole (2002), another magpie was found to have brain AChE activity of 23.6 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue. Westlake et al. (1983) reported a mean value of 4.92 µmol·min1·g1 of tissue for six foxes. We are not aware of published reference values for coyotes or skunks.
|
Almost all of the incidents occurred in Saskatchewan, which reflects the origin of submissions to the laboratory. Between 1991 and 2002, only one eagle was submitted from each of Alberta and the Northwest Territories. In addition to the eagles from Manitoba reported here, other bald eagles from that province that were classified as either suspicious or presumed to have been poisoned by anticholinesterase pesticides were excluded from analysis because the date and location of death were not available. Our findingstogether with those of Allen et al. (1996) and un-confirmed reports of pesticides, especially carbofuran, being used to poison coyotes in other jurisdictionssuggest that secondary poisoning of eagles may be widespread in western North America. Mineau et al. (1999) concluded that bald and golden eagles figured prominently in cases of pesticide abuse in the USA between 1985 and 1995. The impact of anticholinesterase poisoning on regional eagle populations is unknown. We do not know what proportion of poisoning incidents are detected and submitted for examination, but we suspect that specimens from relatively few incidents reach a diagnostic laboratory. Mortality of adults, as occurred in >60% of the eagles examined, is of concern for long-lived birds that are late to mature. Experience in Europe where local population reduction or disappearance of various raptors occurred as a result of use of strychnine baits to control wolves (Canis lupus) and foxes in the past (Bijleveld, 1974) should be considered cautionary.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
| LITERATURE CITED |
|---|
|
|
|---|
AUGSBERGER, T., M. R. SMITH, C. U. METEYER, AND K. A. CONVERSE. 1996. Mortality of passerines adjacent to a North Carolina corn field treated with granular carbofuran. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 32: 113116.[Abstract]
BALCOM, R. 1983. Secondary poisoning of red-shouldered hawks with carbofuran. Journal of Wildlife Management 47: 11291132.
BIJLEVELD, M. 1974. Birds of prey in Europe. The Macmillan Press Ltd., London, UK, 263 pp.
BLAKLEY, B. R. 1984. Epidemiologic and diagnostic considerations of strychnine poisoning in the dog. Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association 184: 4647.[Medline]
, AND M. J. YOLE. 2002. Species differences in normal brain cholinesterase activities of animals and birds. Veterinary and Human Toxicology 44: 129132.[Medline]
BURN, J. D., AND F. A. LEIGHTON. 1996. Further studies of brain cholinesterase: Cholinergic receptor ratios in the diagnosis of acute lethal poisoning of birds by anticholinesterase pesticides. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 32: 216224.[Abstract]
ELLMAN, G. L., K. D. COURTNEY, V. ANDRES, AND R. M. FEATHERSTONE. 1961. A new and rapid colorimetric determination of acetylcholinesterase activity. Biochemical Pharmacology 7: 8895.[Medline]
ELLIOT, J. E., K. M. LANGELIER, P. MINEAU, AND L. K. WILSON. 1996. Poisoning of bald eagles and red-tailed hawks by carbofuran and fensulfothion in the Fraser Delta of British Columbia, Canada. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 32: 486491.[Abstract]
, L. K. WILSON, K. M. LANGELIER, P. MINEAU, AND P. SINCLAIR. 1997. Secondary poisoning of birds of prey by the organophosphorous insecticide phorate. Ecotoxicology 6: 219231
FAIRBROTHER, A. 1996. Cholinesterase-inhibiting pesticides. In Noninfectious diseases of wildlife. 2nd Edition, A. Fairbrother, L. N. Locke, G. L. Hoff (eds.). Iowa State University Press, Ames, Iowa, pp. 5260.
FRIEND, M., AND C. J. FRANSON. 1999. Field manual of wildlife diseases: General field procedures and diseases of birds. Biological Resources Division Information and Technology Report 199901, US Department of the Interior and US Geological Survey, Washington, DC, 426 pp.
GREENBERG, A. E., L. S. CLASCERI, AND A. D. EATON. 1992. Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater. American Public Health Association, Washington, DC, 1086 pp.
HILL, E. F. 1988. Brain cholinesterase activity of apparently normal wild birds. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 24: 5161.[Abstract]
. 1989. Divergent effects of postmortem ambient temperature on organophosphorous and carbamate-inhibited brain cholinesterase activity in birds. Pesticide Biochemistry and Physiology 33: 264275.
. 1995. Organophosphorous and carbamate pesticides. In Handbook of ecotoxicology, D. J. Hoffman, B. A. Rattner, G. H. Burton, Jr., J. Cairns, Jr. (eds.). Lewis Publishers, Boca Raton, Florida, pp. 243274.
, AND W. J. FLEMING. 1982. Anticholinesterase poisoning of birds: Field monitoring and diagnosis of acute poisoning. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry 1: 2738.
HOSEA, R. C., B. J. FINLAYSON, AND E. E. LITTRELL. 2001. Forensic investigative techniques to identify impacts (primary and secondary) from three groups of pesticides on raptors in California. In Pesticides and wildlife, J. J. Johnston (ed.). American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 3851.
KIM, J. S., B. R. BLAKLEY, AND C. G. ROUSSEAUX. 1990. The effects of thiamin on the tissue distribution of lead. Journal of Applied Toxicology 10: 9397.[Medline]
MARTIN, A. D., G. NORMAN, P. I. STANLEY, AND G. E. WESTLAKE. 1981. Use of reactivation techniques for the differential diagnosis of organophosphorous and carbamate pesticide poisoning in birds. Bulletin of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology 26: 775780.[Medline]
MINEAU, P. 1993. The hazard of carbofuran to birds and other vertebrate wildlife. Technical Report Series No. 177. Canadian Wildlife Service Headquarters, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada, Ottawa, 96 pp.
, M. R. FLETCHER, L. C. GLAZER, N. J. THOMAS, C. BRASSARD, L. K. WILSON, J. E. ELLIOT, L. A. LYON, C. J. HENNY, T. BOLLINGER, AND S. L. PORTER. 1999. Poisoning of raptors with organophosphorous pesticides with emphasis on Canada, US, and UK. Journal of Raptor Research 33: 137.
, AND K. R. TUCKER. 2002a. Improving detection of pesticide poisoning in birds. Part I. Journal of Wildlife Rehabilitation 25: 413.
, . 2002b. Improving detection of pesticide poisoning in birds. Part II. Journal of Wildlife Rehabilitation 25: 412.
SMITH, M. R., N. J. THOMAS, AND C. HULSE. 1995. Application of brain cholinesterase reactivation to differentiate between organophosphorous and carbamate pesticide exposure in wild birds. Journal of Wildlife Diseases 31: 263267.[Abstract]
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AGENCY. 1992. Test methods for evaluating solid waste. 3rd Edition. Physical/Chemical Method SW 846, US EPA, Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Responses, Washington, DC.
WESTLAKE G. E., P. J. BUNYAN, A. D. MARTIN, P. I. STANLEY, AND L. C. STEED. 1981. Carbamate poisoning. Effects of selected carbamate pesticides on plasma enzymes and brain esterases of Japanese quail (Coturnix coturnix japonica). Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 29: 779785.[Medline]
, A. D. MARTIN, P. I. STANLEY, AND C. H. WALKER. 1983. Control enzyme levels in the plasma, brain and liver from wild birds and mammals in Britain. Comparative Biochemistry and Physiology 76C: 1524.
Received for publication 21 April 2003.
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. Berny and J.-R. Gaillet ACUTE POISONING OF RED KITES (MILVUS MILVUS) IN FRANCE: DATA FROM THE SAGIR NETWORK J. Wildl. Dis., April 1, 2008; 44(2): 417 - 426. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |